Flux-Core vs. MIG Welding: What’s the Difference?

May.26,2023

Most of new welding worker have a question:what’s the difference between the MIG Welding wire and Flux-Core welding wire ?

Today let's solve the mystery.

Quick Overview

MIG Vs Flux-Core Comparison Table

	MIG	Flux-cored
Setup/Learning curve	Moderate	Moderate
Wire Cost	✅ $$	⛔ $$$
Requires Gas Tank	⛔ Yes	✅ No
Operating Cost	$$	$$
Surface prep	⛔ Bright white metal is best	✅ Works through paint, rust, and dirt
Wind	⛔ Indoor, Less than 5 MPH	✅ Outdoor, Up to 35 MPH
Bead Appearance	✅ No slag, little spatter	⛔ Slag & spatter
Post clean Up	✅ Very Little	⛔ Slag & Spatter Cleaning
Thin stock	✅ Down to 24 ga.	⛔ 1/8 or thicker
Thick stock	⛔ Acceptable with enough power	✅ Good penetration up to 3/8in.
Cast iron	⛔ Possible, but weaker weld	✅ Better penetration, stronger than MIG
Aluminum	✅ Cleaner than stick	⛔ Possible but messier
Mobility	⛔ Harder with gas tanks	✅ Easier without gas tanks

Flux-Cored Wire

Pros

Easy to set up and learn
Works in windy, outdoor conditions
Better penetration handles thick stock well
Affordable
Tolerates some paint, rust, and dirt
Welds cast iron and galvanized steel well
Portable

Cons

Produces slag and splatter that requires cleaning
Aluminum welds are not possible
Will not work on thinner stock without blowing through

Solid MIG Wire

Pros

Simple to use, pull the trigger and weld
No slag, less spatter, cleaner than flux-cored
Handles thin metal well
Solid wire is less likely to tangle or “birdnest” coming off of the spool
Solid wire costs less per pound compared to flux-cored wire
Can produce clean, professional aluminum welds

Cons

A bit harder to set up for a weld (need to set gas flow rate)
More expensive when gas and other costs are added to the wire cost
Needs clean, bright white prep
Wind blows away shielding gas, even light breezes can be a problem
Not a good choice for cast iron
Gas tank makes less portable than flux-cored

Previous: Which welding wire is the right one?

Next: What is flux-cored welding wire?

Products

News

What are the advantages of using electrode... Read More

Air arc gouging tips... Read More

How to use copper coated gouging electrode... Read More

Several Types of Gouging carbon rods... Read More

Flux-Core vs. MIG Welding: What’s the Difference?

Most of new welding worker have a question:what’s the difference between the MIG Welding wire and Flux-Core welding wire ?

Today let's solve the mystery.

Quick Overview

MIG Vs Flux-Core Comparison Table

	MIG	Flux-cored
Setup/Learning curve	Moderate	Moderate
Wire Cost	✅ $$	⛔ $$$
Requires Gas Tank	⛔ Yes	✅ No
Operating Cost	$$	$$
Surface prep	⛔ Bright white metal is best	✅ Works through paint, rust, and dirt
Wind	⛔ Indoor, Less than 5 MPH	✅ Outdoor, Up to 35 MPH
Bead Appearance	✅ No slag, little spatter	⛔ Slag & spatter
Post clean Up	✅ Very Little	⛔ Slag & Spatter Cleaning
Thin stock	✅ Down to 24 ga.	⛔ 1/8 or thicker
Thick stock	⛔ Acceptable with enough power	✅ Good penetration up to 3/8in.
Cast iron	⛔ Possible, but weaker weld	✅ Better penetration, stronger than MIG
Aluminum	✅ Cleaner than stick	⛔ Possible but messier
Mobility	⛔ Harder with gas tanks	✅ Easier without gas tanks

Flux-Cored Wire

Pros

Easy to set up and learn
Works in windy, outdoor conditions
Better penetration handles thick stock well
Affordable
Tolerates some paint, rust, and dirt
Welds cast iron and galvanized steel well
Portable

Cons

Produces slag and splatter that requires cleaning
Aluminum welds are not possible
Will not work on thinner stock without blowing through

Solid MIG Wire

Pros

Simple to use, pull the trigger and weld
No slag, less spatter, cleaner than flux-cored
Handles thin metal well
Solid wire is less likely to tangle or “birdnest” coming off of the spool
Solid wire costs less per pound compared to flux-cored wire
Can produce clean, professional aluminum welds

Cons

A bit harder to set up for a weld (need to set gas flow rate)
More expensive when gas and other costs are added to the wire cost
Needs clean, bright white prep
Wind blows away shielding gas, even light breezes can be a problem
Not a good choice for cast iron
Gas tank makes less portable than flux-cored

Flux-Core vs. MIG Welding: What’s the Difference?

Most of new welding worker have a question:what’s the difference between the MIG Welding wire and Flux-Core welding wire ?

Today let's solve the mystery.

Quick Overview

MIG Vs Flux-Core Comparison Table

	MIG	Flux-cored
Setup/Learning curve	Moderate	Moderate
Wire Cost	✅ $$	⛔ $$$
Requires Gas Tank	⛔ Yes	✅ No
Operating Cost	$$	$$
Surface prep	⛔ Bright white metal is best	✅ Works through paint, rust, and dirt
Wind	⛔ Indoor, Less than 5 MPH	✅ Outdoor, Up to 35 MPH
Bead Appearance	✅ No slag, little spatter	⛔ Slag & spatter
Post clean Up	✅ Very Little	⛔ Slag & Spatter Cleaning
Thin stock	✅ Down to 24 ga.	⛔ 1/8 or thicker
Thick stock	⛔ Acceptable with enough power	✅ Good penetration up to 3/8in.
Cast iron	⛔ Possible, but weaker weld	✅ Better penetration, stronger than MIG
Aluminum	✅ Cleaner than stick	⛔ Possible but messier
Mobility	⛔ Harder with gas tanks	✅ Easier without gas tanks

Flux-Cored Wire

Pros

Easy to set up and learn
Works in windy, outdoor conditions
Better penetration handles thick stock well
Affordable
Tolerates some paint, rust, and dirt
Welds cast iron and galvanized steel well
Portable

Cons

Produces slag and splatter that requires cleaning
Aluminum welds are not possible
Will not work on thinner stock without blowing through

Solid MIG Wire

Pros

Simple to use, pull the trigger and weld
No slag, less spatter, cleaner than flux-cored
Handles thin metal well
Solid wire is less likely to tangle or “birdnest” coming off of the spool
Solid wire costs less per pound compared to flux-cored wire
Can produce clean, professional aluminum welds

Cons

A bit harder to set up for a weld (need to set gas flow rate)
More expensive when gas and other costs are added to the wire cost
Needs clean, bright white prep
Wind blows away shielding gas, even light breezes can be a problem
Not a good choice for cast iron
Gas tank makes less portable than flux-cored